The other day I was grumbling through traffic and dirty snow
when I got cut off by a Escalade, belching grime and a bumpered quote,
“For those who fight for it, Freedom has a flavor the
protected will never know.”
What flavor is that exactly, diesel smoke? But if you Google
it, you’ll find the source of the quote . . . a Vietnam-era, retired Marine
named Tim Croft. After the 1968 Tet Offensive, Croft says he wrote the line on
the back of a C-ration case and gave it to a reporter, where from there, it
passed to the right-wing canon.
The Siege of Khe Sahn is deservedly one of the finest
moments in the history of the US Marine Corps. And if Croft had left his quote presumably intent upon rewarding death
before dishonor, he’d have my respect. However,
and unfortunately, Lance Corporal Croft goes on to say on the website that the
real motivation preceded the battle.
“On this particular Christmas Eve I heard a broadcast on
Armed Forces radio and learned the "Clintonites" were marching on our
Capitol protesting against us! I could not believe what I was hearing. Here we
were fighting for freedom and these low life commies back home were fighting
against us. I was dazed. I just could not understand it. I was hurt to my soul,
angered, and disgusted. (This motivated me to write a message on a C-Ration
case.)”
And he’s lost me in an Arkansas minute. We’re back behind the SUV. He has revealed
that this quote ain’t about dead Marines. It’s about hurt feelings.
In A Few Good Men, when asked why she likes the defendants,
Lt. Cmdr. JoAnne Galloway (Demi Moore) says,
“Because they stand on a wall and say, ‘Nothing's going to
hurt you tonight, not on my watch.‘“
It’s a moment in the film that is overlooked, set against
the pounding of Nicholson’s signature
quote. It actually bookends one of the
lines delivered by Corporal Dawson at the end of the movie when he’s asked why
they are being punished.
“We were supposed to fight for the people who couldn't fight
for themselves.”
Meaning the Marine they accidentally killed. Those two lines are the heart of the play,
which was based upon a story told to Aaron Sorkin, by his sister, a real-live
JAG lawyer. Not the Nicholson line.
In fact Col. Jessup is just another hurt Marine. You people
just don’t appreciate us. We deserve
better. We’ve earned more respect than that.
The first quote above comes out of love and is, not
accidentally, spoken by woman. The
second one comes out of humility. You can’t
fight for me if you think me inferior to you. And you can’t sacrifice yourself
for people you don’t love.
So here’s the truth that you have to handle -- here’s the real
Code. You can’t protect what you don’t love. You don’t defend the Country or the Flag, you defend us. And if we’re
not worthy of your respect, don’t bother. If you don’t love what you protect, you ain’t a Marine, you’re just a
grunt. At best, you’re a mercenary and guess what? No one thanks a mercenary. Yeah, we do need the Marines and I sure don’t
want Hillary, or Demi Moore, or maybe even John Kerry on that wall. But I sure as hell don’t want, or even need,
Nathan Jessup. We need somebody that loves
us.
Not everybody can handle it. It’s a tough job. It’s for the Few.